It was good but the brush is so big it clumps up super easy. I think it would be a great mascara if the brush were just a wee bit smaller. It smells nice and didn't flake, it also has nice coverage and gives the lashes a nice boost.
+ : vegan, cruelty free, very long lasting (not waterproof but does not smudge, even when wearing a mask all day ;), a real wahou effect!, and a very nice price
-: too much plastic (packaging included), formulation could be more natural, hence the 4 stars instead of 5
All in a all, great vegan and cruelty free mascara for conventional beauty!
Hope this help :)